Lives saved from legalized stem cell treatment > Lives lost from military conflicts & flying killer robots / drones 2008-2016
Created by themusicgod1 on 2016-05-06; known on 2017-01-02; judged wrong by two2thehead on 2018-01-31.
- themusicgod1 estimated 58% on 2016-05-06
- ioannes said “Seems hard to assess. ” on 2016-05-06
- two2thehead estimated 1% and said “Lives saved from 2017 to 2117? Probably. Lives saved AND judged accurately/can be assessed properly within the date known (2017-01-01)? No.” on 2016-05-14
- gwern said “this is impossible to assess. deaths from Syria/drone warfare reasonably estimable, but how on earth are you going to estimate # of stem cell-related treatments, much less marginal lives saved? You should withdraw this.” on 2017-01-01
- two2thehead said “Alright. I’ll wait until themusicgod1 comments/decides.” on 2017-01-01
- gwern said “(And to the extent that it’s meaningful, it’s probably wrong. The approved treatments seem minor and for non-fatal conditions: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stem-cell_therapy )” on 2017-01-01
- themusicgod1 changed the deadline from “on 2017-01-01” and made the prediction on 2017-01-13
- themusicgod1 changed the deadline from “on 2017-01-01” and made the prediction on 2017-01-15
- two2thehead said “Since themusicgod1 is banned I’m taking over for this prediction. Gwern’s argument for why it is probably wrong is acceptable to me.” on 2018-01-31
- two2thehead judged this prediction wrong on 2018-01-31.