HP MoR: The Hat and Cloak that interacted with Hermione is Professor McGonagall.
Created by cafesofie on 2012-03-25; known on 2016-04-17; judged wrong by Anubhav on 2015-02-24.
- cafesofie estimated 10% on 2012-03-25
- cafesofie said “Very loose reasoning: H&C was too incompetent to be Quirrel or Dumbledore, and caught themself saying “Time-”. McGonagall was the one to give Harry the Time Turner in the first place. McGonagall hasn’t done much!!!” on 2012-03-25
- gwern estimated 20% and said “mcgonagall’s perspective is guileless, but hat & cloak could be a Imperiused professor… like mcgonagall. not too bright either, apparently, which fits her” on 2012-03-25
- JoshuaZ estimated 2% on 2012-03-25
- Isaac estimated 5% on 2012-03-25
- Grognor estimated 7% and said “20% of your probability mass, though? 20%!?” on 2012-03-26
- roshni estimated 2% and said “McGonagall’s face probably wouldn’t send “a jolt of terrified adrenaline bursting through” Hermione. ” on 2012-03-26
- lavalamp estimated 5% on 2012-03-26
- saturn estimated 2% and said “per roshni” on 2012-03-26
- faws estimated 1% on 2012-03-27
- HonoreDB estimated 0% on 2012-03-27
- average_joe estimated 5% on 2012-03-29
- RobertLumley estimated 10% on 2012-03-31
- Anubhav estimated 0% on 2012-04-02
- moridinamael estimated 2% on 2012-04-02
- Jayson Virissimo estimated 10% on 2012-04-04
- cafesofie changed their prediction from “The Hat and Cloak that interacted with Hermione is Professor McGonagall.” on 2012-04-05
- PlacidPlatypus estimated 1% on 2012-04-19
- disinter estimated 0% and said “0.1%” on 2012-04-20
- Oscar_Cunningham estimated 3% on 2012-04-20
- Sarokrae estimated 2% on 2012-04-29
- Flailingjunk estimated 0% on 2012-09-21
- cafesofie changed the deadline from “on 2013-01-01” on 2013-04-17
- Anubhav said “Voldy just admitted to being him. ” on 2015-02-24
- Anubhav judged this prediction wrong on 2015-02-24.